The Nintendo Effect

-by Dylan DiBona

I was recently watching a gaming podcast where the topic of Nintendo game reviews came up. They discussed if Nintendo gets an unfair bias from reviewers due to nostalgia. The most recent case is The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild; a game with insane critical praise, gaining a 98 on Metacritic, just one point under the beloved Ocarina of Time. After playing and completing all 120 shrines, getting all memories and both endings, I don’t feel like Breath of the Wild is a 98.
Image result for NintendoMany gaming journalists are in the the industry thanks to Nintendo creating their love of gaming from an early age. It’s not to say that Nintendo was the only game company back in the day, I’m sure there are plenty of journalists out there who started because of Sonic and Knuckles.

But when it comes to the most influential games and mechanics, their often cited as product of Nintendo. Whether it be 3D camera control in Super Mario 64 or locking onto enemies from Ocarina of Time, Nintendo has undoubtedly created some staple mechanics seen in almost every game out there. It’s important to respect that history and give credit when due, because where would gaming be without those landmarks?

It happened again with Super Mario Galaxy on the Wii. Critics and fans alike praised the breath of fresh air Nintendo gave to a seemingly repetitive series. But in hindsight, did Galaxy really revolutionize gaming? No. It’s really only fair to say it changed just Mario.

And that’s what gets me on Breath of the Wild; sure it’s new for Zelda but not gaming as a whole. This time Nintendo did the borrowing of ideas. The overworld towers remind me of Assassins Creed, the horse mechanics Red Dead Redemption, some scenery and tones from Shadow of the Colossus. And the stuff that does feel unique like the weapon durability- nobody likes that.

In my review I said Breath of the Wild was fantastic and I stick by that. The physics and elements are my biggest praise. I’ve seen people “cheat” puzzles by coming up with their own solutions which is unlike any other Zelda. I’m glad to see the game receive such love from fans on social media. I’m not trying to put a damper on anybody’s fun. I just want to make sure we’re analyzing this game, and other Nintendo products as video games and not Nintendo games. Keeping the lid closed will only allow skewed opinions which help absolutely nobody. It doesn’t help journalists keep their credibility, it doesn’t help consumers make smart opinions on their purchases and it doesn’t help Nintendo figure out what their next step towards improvement should be.

Image result for Nintendo

I love Nintendo probably more than the average guy, but I’m not afraid to call them out when they mess up. Federation Force, Star Fox Zero, New Super Mario Bros, etc. I’m also one of the first to praise them when it’s do. I don’t think Breath of the Wild is an industry changer, or a 98 on Metacritics. But I do think it’s a damn good game. Launching alongside the Switch may have also sealed it’s deal for fans; who doesn’t get excited for a Nintendo console launch?

I think when the smoke clears in a couple of months everybody will see that Breath of the Wild is a great game, just not as revolutionary as originally thought. And if they don’t, that’s great! That’s what’s so exciting and beautiful about opinions, nobody’s right or wrong.


So what do you guys think? Is Breath of the Wild a 10/10? Do Nintendo games get unfairly scored? Reply in the comments below! As always, thanks for reading.


3 thoughts on “The Nintendo Effect

  1. I think people who like Nintendo, like Nintendo but they review the games honestly in terms of their experience. People who don’t like Nintendo, don’t like Nintendo and tend to be pretty critical of anything related to Nintendo. But that hasn’t changed from a long time ago.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I haven’t played BotW yet, but I think the most important thing for any medium – and especially for ones that you love – is to be able to look at it with a critical eye. You want that “thing” (whatever it is) to be the best version of itself. That’s love, not just blindingly accepting nonsense just because of your feelings/nostalgia.

    Ahem that took I turn I wasn’t expecting, but it’s true for games or I suppose anything else you’d like to apply that to… We seem to have gotten away from objective critiques, at any rate. You are pro-Nintendo or anti-Nintendo. You love it or hate it. I rarely see *critiques* of games, just reviews or news. Eventually the video game medium will be respected enough that people will feel comfortable criticizing it, knowing it’s not because we *don’t* love games, it’s because we *do*.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Nintendo first party games have a reputation of being very good so I think many reviewers get scared about being too critical. The internet can also be savage. I’ve seen some sites give Breath of the Wild an overall positive score, but they still got swamped with hate for giving it a seven or eight out of ten.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s